Picky Eaters

I don't understand picky eaters. That's probably because I'm not one. I've seen a number of different styles of picky eaters. They all have their reasons for choosing to eat or not eat something, and I have chosen to make observations about these things (as you may have noticed by a blog full of these observations).

Let's get right down the various kinds of picky eaters. I'll discuss each type of picky eater, or at least each general categorization for the pickiness, which I have noticed:

Visual Discrimination
These are the people that don't eat something based off of how it looks. It could be that they don't like how something glistens (or doesn't). It could be because the appearance of something brings back some hurtful memory of something they've seen previously which is obviously unappetizing. There are a number of reasons, none of which I can claim to understand or even possibly enumerate, but this is the rough idea.
Textural Discrimination
Grapes remind them of eyeballs, spaghetti reminds them of innards, Rice Krispies remind them of insects, tomatoes remind them of snot… I wish I were making this stuff up. Maybe my imagination has been fried by TV, the internet, and video games… but honestly. Why would these things come to their mind while eating? It's like the memory trick to remember people's names by associating something with somebody based off of their looks, their name, their job, or whatever. It's like that… except all wrong.
Nasal Discrimination
Smell. Again, I think this is all based off of poor association. I can understand how something seriously doesn't smell good (like burnt popcorn). But it seems that people can still be discriminating against food for this reason. This is probably my most forgivable offense, since the nose lies so infrequently.
Touching Food
This is like a toddler. They like to separate out their food into different areas on their plate. Nothing can be touching, otherwise that part of both kinds of food is contaminated and can't be eaten. I know somebody (who very well could read this, and even fess up to it) who would get upset if her salad touched anything else on the plate. You always know when it happens, since the salad dressing is there, staring at you on the other piece of food. Well, she would leave both that piece of food, and the infringing salad on her plate. It's not like her mouth totally cleanses itself of the previous flavors or food residue before her next bite… so what's the difference? Go figure.
Health Conscious
We've seen these people before. Maybe you're one of them. These are the people who can't eat something without consulting the Nutritional Information. They ask for the list at fast food restaurants (which is a miracle that they've even entered). They seem to have information memorized about everything out there? “That cookie? 200 calories. That drink? 150 calories. That sandwich? With all the saturated fat in it, I can't even believe you're still alive.” Don't get me wrong. I can understand why somebody is health conscious to some extent. They're trying to be healthy and not eat things that will make their body shut down in another year or two. There's no problem with that, but these are the people that seem to criticize everything available. They've got issues with everything except rice cakes, which they also probably dislike due to sodium or something like that.
Assumed Knowledge
This is the newest addition to my observations, and possibly the most confusing. These are the people that think they know how an experience with food will be, based off of any of the previously listed things, or based off of prior experience with a similar food, or even with some of the composing foods. For example: if they were to have eaten grilled onions on a previous occasion (and they didn't like them), yet you have made a new recipe with revolutionary onions that nobody has eaten previously… not gonna eat it (say it like Dana Carvey doing his George Bush Sr. impersonation on Saturday Night Live). Those onions you made could be just a small portion of a favorite meal of this person, yet they won't try them, and possibly could even boycott anything involving them. Part of me is really tempted to try to feed these people the nastiest stuff out there, but in miniscule portions in existing foods, and not tell them. Little do they know I've pureed those grilled onions and put them into the sauce which flavored that steak. What I've said so far about these types of people is really just the tip of the iceberg… if even that. Truly perplexing people.

These discriminations have nothing to do with other reasons for being a picky eater. Horribly allergic to peanuts or wheat or dairy or something like that? Be my guest. Vegetarian or vegan or something like that? Although I think they're weird as well, I can understand their scrutiny. Religious restrictions? You're not going to catch any beef from me about that.

I'll admit here that I'm not the least discriminating person out there. I don't particularly care for water chestnuts and jicama. Both are fairly flavorless and pointless. I won't pick them out, but you won't find me snacking on them by themselves (though I haven't tried either one by itself for a number of years).

What's the point here? There is no point. I just think these people are interesting and have chosen this space of mine to comment fully about them. Maybe you're one of them. Maybe you've seen other types of pickiness. I'm more than interested in hearing about it.

8 Comments

what if you have more than one confession? I bet there are other people who don't like their salads touching their other food. Good thing I'm the grown-up now who can use her own salad plate any time she wants. Ahh -total control. Then there is my one-year old who eats anything in sight without prejudice. Fistfuls of chimichanga innards, some broccoli caught in there, a bit of cereal- whatever- it's all good. Surely we're not related.

I proudly count myself among the picky eaters of the world. I prefer the term discriminating. This is an entirely different category, having everything to do with quality of the food experience, weighed against the calories & hunger. Much of the food out there is just not worth the calories. I prefer to save myself for the good stuff!

Another funny thing kind of the other end of the spectrum is how some people will eat anything if it has a special condiment on it. Whether it be ketchup, ranch, mustard or whatever. I think smaller children especially fall into this category. I know a younger girl that puts ketchup on everything.......chicken, fries, toast, etc. That which turns others' stomachs makes food edible again for others.

The indiscriminate are another fascination, but one to which I can more easily relate. I'll admit that at one point in my life I ate nearly anything, as long as I could put a little bit of A1 steak sauce on it. The food itself was nasty enough and the A1 was so delicious in comparison and I was so hungry for food that I finished off that bottle of steak sauce within a week on nor more than 10 meals. Ah… what fun.

I find picky eaters tedious... mainly because they don't just suffer in hunger and silence but often share their issues with any unsuspecting eater with comments such as, "I can't believe you're going to eat that." OR- my personal favorite- sounding as if and making a face as it to throw-up- nice... OR- those who wipe an entire food group off the list of possible choices- hello?! I KNOW they have not tried every one of that food category. Like Pedro, I suffer from not being picky enough- there are some foods though- blue cheese or lima beans- "I can't believe people like them"- they make me want to hurl... :)

I don't mind people who just don't like the odd ingredient or dish. But when the something they don't like numbers into the hundreds, what a shame. Just think what they are missing.

I periodically revist items I have not enjoyed in the past to see if my taste has changed. Recently, this brought brussel sprouts to my plate. Who knew they could be so, well, delightful?

Cheers.

It's those über picky people that drive me nuts. Almost vegetarian, you pegged it right on. Just think of what they're missing… what a shame.

Yo Peter, its Aaron from your former worklife. I found your blag and I like what I see.

I'd like to suggest another category: Controlled by Condiments. These people make all of their decisions on condiments. They won't eat pizza unless they can dip it in ranch. They won't eat authentic BBQ that isn't smothered in cheap sauce because they are used to Famous Daves and the sauce smothering. They won't eat a hamburger or sandwich because mustard is present.

It drives me insane.

Leave a comment

Recent Entries

  • Yellowstone 2008

    Our little family had the pleasure of visiting our nation's best national park almost two months ago. My wonderful aunt and uncle were kind enough...

  • Just a little Spooked

    This evening after dinner, I was legitimately thrown off guard by Cecilia… when she read to me. I said to myself, “Self, she's three. She...

  • Halloween 2008

    Despite the rain this evening, the two of them brought in somewhere between eight and nine pounds of candy, almost certainly because of their costumes:Props...

  • Beautiful Fall Colors

    We went and took pictures of the girls today for our Christmas card (Maria is very much on the ball this year). I just wanted...

  • I Hope You're Sitting Down

    I hope you're seated – chances are you are already. It might be best if it were a chair that could recline a bit, and...

Close